If you have federal student loans, you've probably felt the ground shift under you this year. The SAVE plan is gone, a new plan called RAP has taken its place, and two older plans are on a countdown clock. If you're trying to sort out RAP vs. IBR, or wondering whether income-driven repayment still makes sense for you, you're not alone.
"Income-driven repayment," or IDR, is simply a family of federal repayment plans that set your monthly student loan payment based on how much you earn rather than how much you owe. That idea hasn't changed. What has changed is which plans exist, how they calculate your payment, and how long you'll be in repayment before any remaining balance is forgiven.
This guide walks through what RAP is, how its payment formula works, how it stacks up against IBR and the sunsetting PAYE and ICR plans, and what happened to SAVE, plus whether switching plans makes sense for you and how to do it.
What Does "Income-Driven Repayment" Actually Mean?
Under the standard federal repayment plan, your monthly payment is calculated to pay off your loan in a fixed number of years, regardless of what you earn. Income-driven repayment flips that: your payment is a percentage of your income, and it moves up or down as your income changes. If your balance still isn't fully paid off after a set number of years of qualifying payments, the remaining amount is forgiven.
Before 2026, there were four IDR plans: IBR, PAYE, ICR, and SAVE. Now there are two paths forward: RAP, brand new as of July 1, 2026, and IBR, an older plan that survived the overhaul. PAYE and ICR still exist for now but are being phased out, and SAVE no longer exists as an enrollment option at all.
What Happened to the SAVE Plan?
SAVE (Saving on a Valuable Education) was a Biden-era plan that shielded a large amount of income from the payment calculation, offering some of the lowest monthly payments any IDR plan has ever produced. It was challenged in court almost immediately after launch, and a federal appeals court order on March 10, 2026 effectively ended it: the Eighth Circuit directed the lower court to reverse an earlier dismissal of the case, and the Department of Education has since confirmed SAVE is closed to new enrollment and winding down entirely.
If you were on SAVE, you were likely placed in an interest-accruing forbearance while the litigation played out. Starting in the second half of 2026, loan servicers began sending formal 90-day notices requiring SAVE borrowers to choose a new plan or be automatically moved into standard repayment once their forbearance ends. Notices are going out in waves through the end of 2026, and most affected borrowers will be back in active repayment by early fall. If you haven't chosen a plan yet, check your loan servicer account today, this is the most time-sensitive item in this article.
What Is RAP (Repayment Assistance Plan) and How Are Payments Calculated?
RAP is the new federal income-driven repayment plan created by 2025 legislation (the One Big Beautiful Bill Act) and launched July 1, 2026, alongside a separate Tiered Standard Repayment Plan. RAP is now the default, and for anyone taking out a new federal loan on or after July 1, 2026, it's the only income-driven option available.
How RAP's Payment Formula Works
RAP calculates your monthly payment as a percentage of your full adjusted gross income (AGI), the figure from your tax return, before the kind of poverty-line "buffer" older IDR plans use. The percentage rises in steps: roughly 1% of AGI at the lowest income levels, climbing in 1-point increments for every $10,000 of additional income, up to a 10% cap for higher earners. Borrowers with very low AGI still owe a flat $10 minimum; RAP doesn't offer a true $0 payment the way SAVE sometimes did. One real break: your payment drops by $50 per month for each dependent you claim on your taxes.
Here's the detail that trips people up: because RAP applies its percentage to full AGI instead of a "discretionary income" figure with a poverty-line exclusion, it often produces a noticeably higher monthly payment than SAVE would have for the same income. One widely cited example: a family of four earning around $81,000 was estimated to see payments rise from roughly $36 a month under SAVE to several hundred dollars a month under RAP. Your own numbers depend on your income, family size, and loan balance, but the direction of that gap is well documented and worth planning for.
RAP's Interest Subsidy: No More Negative Amortization
There's genuinely good news in RAP's formula: if your payment isn't large enough to cover that month's accrued interest, the government subsidizes the unpaid interest rather than adding it to your balance. That means your loan can't grow simply because your payment was small, a problem known as "negative amortization" that borrowers on some older plans have struggled with for years. In this respect, RAP behaves a lot like SAVE did.
RAP also counts toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), which forgives remaining balances after 10 years (120 qualifying payments) for people working full-time in government or nonprofit jobs. For borrowers taking out their first federal loans on or after July 1, 2026, RAP is the only IDR plan that counts toward PSLF. One exception: Parent PLUS borrowers who take out new loans on or after July 1, 2026 are not eligible for RAP.
RAP vs. IBR vs. PAYE/ICR: A Side-by-Side Comparison
Here's how the current options compare on the three things that matter most: how your payment is calculated, how long until forgiveness, and whether the plan is open to you today.
| Plan | Payment Formula | Forgiveness Timeline | Available Today? |
|---|---|---|---|
| RAP | 1%-10% of full AGI, in brackets; $10/month minimum; -$50/month per dependent | 30 years (10 years / 120 payments for PSLF) | Yes - launched 7/1/2026; only IDR option for new federal borrowing after that date |
| IBR | 10% of discretionary income (loans 7/1/2014+) or 15% (older loans); excludes 150% of poverty line | 20 years (newer loans) or 25 years (older loans) | Yes - loans disbursed before 7/1/2026; remains available long-term |
| PAYE | 10% of discretionary income; 150% poverty-line protection | 20 years | Closed to most new enrollment; sunsets 7/1/2028 |
| ICR | Lesser of 20% of discretionary income or a fixed 12-year payment; 100% poverty-line protection | 25 years | Closed to most new enrollment; sunsets 7/1/2028 |
| SAVE | Formerly 5%-10% of discretionary income, generous poverty-line shield | N/A | No - blocked by appeals court, 3/10/2026; borrowers being transitioned out |
Is IBR Still Available in 2026?
Yes. IBR (Income-Based Repayment) is a separate, older statutory plan, and it isn't being eliminated the way PAYE, ICR, and SAVE are. If your federal loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026, and you haven't taken out any new loan or consolidation loan since then, you can still enroll in IBR. A rule that used to gate IBR behind a "partial financial hardship" test was removed effective December 22, 2025, making IBR somewhat easier to qualify for.
IBR calculates payments as a percentage of discretionary income, your AGI minus 150% of the federal poverty guideline for your family size, rather than your full AGI. Depending on when your loans were first disbursed, that's 10% of discretionary income with forgiveness after 20 years, or 15% with forgiveness after 25 years. Because it protects a slice of your income from the calculation entirely, IBR can produce a meaningfully lower payment than RAP for borrowers with modest incomes, even on identical loans and income.
The catch: after July 1, 2028, PAYE and ICR close for good, and IBR becomes one of only two IDR options left, alongside RAP, for anyone with loans from before July 1, 2026. If you're on PAYE, ICR, or transitioning off SAVE, actively choose between IBR and RAP before that deadline rather than leaving it to chance.
What's Happening to PAYE and ICR?
PAYE (Pay As You Earn) and ICR (Income-Contingent Repayment) are both being phased out under the same 2025 legislation that created RAP. Both are scheduled to close entirely by July 1, 2028, though the Department of Education is expected to cut off new enrollment earlier, likely late 2027 or early 2028, to give servicers time to transition borrowers.
PAYE uses the same formula as "new borrower" IBR: 10% of discretionary income, 20-year forgiveness, 150% poverty-line protection. ICR is less generous: the lesser of 20% of discretionary income or a fixed 12-year payment, only 100% poverty-line protection, and 25-year forgiveness. Nothing changes automatically today if you're enrolled in either plan, but you need a plan for 2028. If you take no action, your servicer will eventually move you into IBR or RAP on its own timeline, which may not be the cheapest plan for you.
The Pros and Cons of RAP's 30-Year Forgiveness Timeline
Thirty years is longer than any prior IDR forgiveness timeline; SAVE, IBR, PAYE, and ICR all forgave balances in 20 to 25 years. That's a real trade-off worth sitting with honestly.
Where RAP Helps
- No negative amortization. Your balance can't balloon past what you borrowed just because a payment was small.
- A guaranteed forgiveness date. Even at 30 years, there's a defined end point for your balance.
- PSLF still runs on 10 years. If you qualify for PSLF, RAP's 30-year clock is irrelevant; forgiveness still arrives after 120 qualifying payments.
- Dependents lower your bill. The $50-per-dependent reduction is a real, if modest, nod to family financial pressure.
Where RAP Falls Short
- Higher monthly payments. Full-AGI pricing can cost noticeably more than SAVE, and sometimes more than IBR, for the same income.
- A decade longer to forgiveness. That's more total interest paid for borrowers who don't reach forgiveness through PSLF.
- No $0 payment option. The $10 minimum means even very low earners owe something every month.
- It's brand new. Launched July 2026, RAP doesn't yet have a track record on recertification or edge cases.
Who Should Consider Switching Plans, and Who Shouldn't?
There's no single right answer; it depends on your income, loan type, family size, and how close you are to forgiveness.
- Consider IBR if: your loans predate July 1, 2026 and your income is modest relative to family size; the poverty-line protection RAP lacks can mean a noticeably lower bill.
- Consider RAP if: you're pursuing PSLF with loans from on or after July 1, 2026 (it's your only option), or the no-negative-amortization guarantee matters more to you than the lowest possible bill.
- Think twice before switching away from IBR, PAYE, or ICR if: you're already years into your forgiveness clock. Switching can affect how qualifying payments carry over, so confirm with your servicer or the Loan Simulator first.
- Don't panic if you were on SAVE. You have a 90-day notice window to choose a plan before auto-enrollment in standard repayment, which is usually the costliest outcome of all.
How to Apply for or Switch Repayment Plans
- Log in at StudentAid.gov for the IDR application, or call your servicer, who can confirm which plans you're eligible for based on your loan disbursement dates.
- Run the Loan Simulator at StudentAid.gov first. It compares estimated payments and total costs across RAP, IBR, and any other plan you qualify for.
- Have your latest tax return ready; both RAP and IBR are built on your AGI, and you'll typically consent to IRS data sharing during the application.
- Recertify your income every year, and if you're pursuing PSLF, update your employment certification at the same time you choose your plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Not for most monthly budgets. RAP generally costs more per month because it's based on full AGI rather than a discretionary-income figure with a large poverty-line exclusion. Its advantages are that it's actually available and it prevents your balance from growing through unpaid interest.
Yes, as long as your federal loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026, and you haven't taken out a new loan or consolidation since. IBR remains open with no announced end date, unlike PAYE and ICR.
Yes. On-time RAP payments count toward the 120 qualifying payments needed for PSLF. For borrowers taking out their first federal loans on or after July 1, 2026, RAP is the only IDR plan that counts toward PSLF.
You'll be automatically placed on standard repayment, which is not income-driven and can mean a much higher fixed payment. If an income-based payment matters to your budget, actively choose RAP or IBR instead of waiting.
For many borrowers, yes, especially middle-income borrowers with smaller families. But it isn't universal; your income, family size, and dependents all affect the outcome, so run your numbers through the Loan Simulator before assuming either way.
AGI is your total income minus certain adjustments, as reported on your tax return. "Discretionary income," used by IBR, PAYE, and ICR, subtracts a poverty-line-based buffer from AGI before applying the payment percentage. RAP skips that subtraction and applies its percentage directly to AGI, which is a major reason its payments run higher.
Repayment plan rules are moving fast, and RAP vs. IBR is just one piece of a bigger picture that includes PSLF, consolidation, and how forgiveness gets taxed.
If this article helped you get oriented, head to our Student Loans, Education Debt & Repayment lessons at financialconfidence.net/courses/ to keep building your plan, one plain-English lesson at a time.
Explore Free CoursesLet us know if this article was useful, it helps us know what to keep improving.
Thanks for letting us know!